What’s the Difference Between Air And Water Rowing Machines?

22 minutes read

Air and water rowing machines both provide resistance for indoor rowing workouts, but they achieve this through different mechanisms, leading to distinct experiences. Air rowing machines use a flywheel with fan blades; resistance is generated as you pull, because of the air displaced by the blades. The resistance in air rowers is dynamic, meaning the harder and faster you row, the more resistance you feel, which can simulate the feel of rowing on water to some extent. These machines tend to be noisy due to the airflow.


Water rowing machines, on the other hand, utilize a water-filled tank as their resistance system. As you row, paddles move through the water, creating resistance that naturally adjusts to your speed and strength. This generates a smooth and consistent rowing experience with sounds reminiscent of actual water rowing, which some users find more soothing and engaging. The resistance mimics the fluid dynamics of real rowing more closely than air rowers. Generally, water rowers are quieter than air rowers, except for the swooshing sound of water, which many find pleasant.


In terms of maintenance, water rowers might require more attention, like periodic water treatment to prevent algae growth in the tank. Preference for either type depends largely on what a user values in experience, noise level, and maintenance effort.

Best Rowing Machines of March 2025

1
YOSUDA Water Rowing Machines for Home Use- Foldable Rower Machine 400LBS Weight Capacity with Dedicated Monitor & Bluetooth APP, Comfortable Seat

Rating is 5 out of 5

YOSUDA Water Rowing Machines for Home Use- Foldable Rower Machine 400LBS Weight Capacity with Dedicated Monitor & Bluetooth APP, Comfortable Seat

  • Revolutionary 180° Foldable Storage Design: Save space in your home with our innovative folding feature; The elegant beech wood finish adds a stylish touch, making it blend seamlessly with your home decoration
  • Robust 400 lbs Capacity: The YOSUDA water rowing machine, meticulously crafted from solid beech wood, offers exceptional durability and stability; Accommodating users up to 78.74 inches tall, it’s the perfect fit for nearly every member of your family
  • Never Worry Leaking Problem: The oversized tank of the folding rowing machine provides ample resistance for your workout; With patented sealing technology, no need to drain after use and no water leakage when stored upright
  • Full-Body Muscle Workout: Featuring an oversized water tank, this water rower delivers ample resistance; Each stroke engages 90% of your muscle groups; All stages users get an effective workout whether you are beginners or professionals
2
Concept2 RowErg Model D Indoor Rowing Machine Gray Color with PM5 Monitor, Device Holder, Adjustable Air Resistance, Easy Storage

Rating is 4.9 out of 5

Concept2 RowErg Model D Indoor Rowing Machine Gray Color with PM5 Monitor, Device Holder, Adjustable Air Resistance, Easy Storage

  • Integrated Device Holder allows you to keep your Smart Phone or Tablet securely in place. Compatible with over 40+ apps.
  • 14-inch seat height fits most uses. Adjustable footrests and ergonomic handle
  • Indoor rowing is an effective full-body and low-impact workout; flywheel design minimizes noise while maximizing a smooth feel
  • Easily separates into two pieces for storage. Caster wheels make it mobile. Construction: Aluminum front legs and steel rear legs.
3
YOSUDA Magnetic Rowing Machine 350 LB Weight Capacity - Rower Machine for Home Use with LCD Monitor, Tablet Holder and Comfortable Seat Cushion-New Version

Rating is 4.8 out of 5

YOSUDA Magnetic Rowing Machine 350 LB Weight Capacity - Rower Machine for Home Use with LCD Monitor, Tablet Holder and Comfortable Seat Cushion-New Version

  • Choose YOSUDA: Design and produce top-quality exercise machines for home use for over 20 years. YOSUDA has been chosed by more than 3,000,000 families and we will always stand behind our product
  • 10× 10 Powerful Magnetic: Equipped with a 10-lb flywheel and high-quality magnetic control system, this rower machine provides enough resistance. All stages users can get an effective workout whether you are a beginner or an advanced user
  • Dual Silent System: The non-contact magnetic resistance system delivers a virtually silent rowing experience. High-density steel reduces noise, changing your daily rowing into pleasure. You can enjoy your workout without worries anytime
  • 6-Types of Data Disply: The 3.45-inch LCD monitor clearly displays the rowing data. You can put the phone or tablet on the holder to enjoy the videos or music
4
Rowing Machine, MERACH Bluetooth Magnetic Rower Machine with Dual Slide Rail, 16 Levels of Electromagnetic Resistance, Max 350lb Weight Capacity, App Compatible, Rowing Machines for Home Use

Rating is 4.7 out of 5

Rowing Machine, MERACH Bluetooth Magnetic Rower Machine with Dual Slide Rail, 16 Levels of Electromagnetic Resistance, Max 350lb Weight Capacity, App Compatible, Rowing Machines for Home Use

  • Upgraded Electromagnetic Resistance: The electromagnetic flywheel provides more stable and sufficient power than traditional magnetic resistance, ensuring a more efficient and smooth workout experience
  • Smart Electronic Control: Precisely manage 16 levels of electromagnetic resistance with a simple twist. Pull to start, and enjoy automatic resistance adjustment via the MERACH app, freeing your hands for an uninterrupted workout.
  • Less Noise While Rowing: Customized smooth and quiet magnetic flywheel system makes the workout extremely quiet. Q1S rower machine for home avoids the worries of bothering other family members.
  • Easy Assemble: The Merach rowing machine can be easily assembled within 30 mins by most users. It is partially pre-assembled and can be moved around easily.
5
Rowing Machine,Wenoker Magnetic Rower Machine for Home,350 LB Weight Capacity, Smooth Whisper Quiet with LCD Monitor Tablet Holder & Comfortable Seat Cushion, Compact and Saves Space

Rating is 4.6 out of 5

Rowing Machine,Wenoker Magnetic Rower Machine for Home,350 LB Weight Capacity, Smooth Whisper Quiet with LCD Monitor Tablet Holder & Comfortable Seat Cushion, Compact and Saves Space

  • [Smooth & Quiet Magnetic Resistance] Wenoker rowing machine is equipped with an advanced magnetic resistance system. With noise levels <30 DB, you can enjoy rowing quietly without disturbing your family or neighbors. It stays stable and never wobbles even when using it with high and constant resistance. Unlike not much friendly air and water resistance rowers: only the faster you pull, the more resistance they provides.
  • [Ergonomic Design Details] The ergonomically designed cushion seat of this rower machine ensures support and coziness. The long slide fits users from 4'5'' to 6'2'', making it a great machine for the whole household. With a high-quality textured silicone handle, sweaty hands won’t slip off as easily, and it has an additional protective covering to prevent blisters. The easy-on-and-off foot strap system works for different shoe sizes, which is a truly customizable rowing machine.
  • [LCD monitor & Tablet Holder] The LCD monitor can track your fitness performance while rowing, including time, speed, distance, calories burned. You can use this data to develop your fitness plan. Place your mobile devices on the stand, and you can exercise while watching videos, providing a very comfortable fitness experience. (Tablet not included.)
  • [Total Body Workout] This magnetic rowing machine is an efficient machine for total body muscle workouts. Engage and strengthen legs, glutes, core, back, arms & shoulders. It burns serious calories and work your muscular and cardiovascular systems.
6
MERACH Rowing Machines for Home, Adjustable Air Resistance Professional Indoor Rowing Machine, Ergonomic Comfort Seat, Performance Monitor and Device Holder, Easy Storage

Rating is 4.5 out of 5

MERACH Rowing Machines for Home, Adjustable Air Resistance Professional Indoor Rowing Machine, Ergonomic Comfort Seat, Performance Monitor and Device Holder, Easy Storage

  • Full-Body Low-Impact Workout: Indoor rowing provides an effective full-body, low-impact exercise. In just 20 minutes, you can engage over 86% of your major muscle groups, all without needing to go outdoors
  • Air Resistance System: 10-level air resistance system with up to 110 lbs of peak resistance, catering to various workout intensities
  • Designed for Taller Users: Extended track with durable, high-quality steel construction, supports up to 350 lbs, ensuring both safety and comfort during workouts
  • Professional Performance Monitor: Delivers accurate workout data and connects via Bluetooth to the Merach APP. Includes a device holder for your smartphone or tablet
7
MERACH Magnetic Rowing Machines for Home, Foldable Rowing Machine with 16-Level, Compact Row Saves 20% Space, 350 LBS Load Capacity, Free MERACH App and 1000+ Champion Coaching Course & Games

Rating is 4.4 out of 5

MERACH Magnetic Rowing Machines for Home, Foldable Rowing Machine with 16-Level, Compact Row Saves 20% Space, 350 LBS Load Capacity, Free MERACH App and 1000+ Champion Coaching Course & Games

  • Next-Level Rowing Performance: The shark-inspired appearance enhances both aesthetics and performance, boosting resistance by over 11% compared to regular rowing machine, with 16 adjustable levels for a more efficient workout.
  • Compact & Foldable for Small Spaces: With a space-saving design that reduces footprint by 20%, this rowing machine is ideal for apartments or limited spaces, offering easy storage without sacrificing performance.
  • Full-Body Low-Impact Workout: Indoor rowing provides an effective full-body, low-impact exercise. In just 20 minutes, you can engage over 86% of your major muscle groups, all without needing to go outdoors
  • Unlock 1000+ Workouts & Games: Connect via Bluetooth to the exclusive MERACH App, featuring over 1,000 interactive courses and fun games. Plus, enjoy 6 months of free premium membership with your purchase!
  • Train Like a Champion: Access exclusive rowing tutorials and personalized fat-burning plans designed by champion coaches, all while the professional monitor keeps you on track with detailed performance metrics.
8
Rowing Machine, MOSUNY Magnetic Rowing Machines for Home 350 LB Weight Capacity, 16 Levels Resistance Row Machine with Dual Slide Rail, Bluetooth, App Compatible 2025

Rating is 4.3 out of 5

Rowing Machine, MOSUNY Magnetic Rowing Machines for Home 350 LB Weight Capacity, 16 Levels Resistance Row Machine with Dual Slide Rail, Bluetooth, App Compatible 2025

  • 16-Level Powerful Magnetic:MOSUNY rowing machine is equipped with a high-quality magnetic control system and an upgraded 16-level adjustable resistance. It allows users to find the optimal resistance intensity for their needs, whether they are elderly individuals undergoing rehabilitation training, or fitness enthusiasts seeking to build muscle. Unlike other 8-level row machine, the 16-Level resistance have more varied sporting experience.
  • Bluetooth App Compatible: Connect your smartphone or device to the rowing machine via Bluetooth, fully master real-time rowing data! This rowing machine is also compatible with the KINOMAP APP, which allows you to immerse yourself in the splash of nature while rowing at home! You can also visit professional rowing training courses, discover new challenges and improve yourself!
  • Dual Slide Rail, Stable & Smooth Design: We use a thickened commercial quality steel on this magnetic rowing machine to give it a better texture, durability, and higher load, supporting a maximum load of 350 pounds. Our dual slide rail is more stable than a single slide rail, won't wobble even with intense exercise, allowing you to maximize your potential.
  • 7-Types of Data Disply: The LCD monitor tracks your rowing time, counts, total count, 500 meters in time, frequency, distance, and calories in real time, allowing you to track your progress towards your goals. The device holder lets you place your smartphone and IPAD to enjoy videos or music while using the rower machine.


What is a foldable rowing machine?

A foldable rowing machine is a type of exercise equipment designed to simulate the motion of rowing a boat, providing a full-body workout. The key feature of this type of rowing machine is its ability to fold up for easy storage, making it ideal for people with limited space at home. When not in use, it can be collapsed to take up less room, allowing for more convenient storage in closets, under beds, or against walls. Foldable rowing machines often feature a hinge point in the frame that allows the machine to be easily folded and unfolded. They typically offer the same resistance types as non-foldable models, including magnetic, hydraulic, water, and air resistance, catering to various fitness levels and preferences.


How to clean a water rowing machine?

Cleaning a water rowing machine is essential to maintain its condition and extend its lifespan. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to clean it effectively:

  1. Gather Supplies: Soft cloths or microfiber towels Mild detergent or all-purpose cleaner Water Vacuum with a soft brush attachment (optional) Sanitary tablets (appropriate for your water tank if necessary) Lubricant for moving parts (refer to manufacturer's recommendations)
  2. General Cleaning: Frame: Use a soft cloth dampened with water and a mild detergent to wipe down the frame. Avoid using harsh chemicals that could damage the finish. Make sure to dry it thoroughly to prevent rust or corrosion. Seat and Rails: Clean the seat and rails thoroughly to remove dust and sweat. Use a mild cleaner and a soft cloth, ensuring you dry them well afterward. Handle and Footrests: These areas can accumulate sweat and dirt, so clean them with a mild detergent solution, then dry them with a clean cloth.
  3. Water Tank Maintenance: Exterior Cleaning: Keep the tank clear by wiping it with a damp cloth. Interior Cleaning: Follow manufacturer instructions for maintaining the water inside the tank. Some manufacturers recommend using specific water treatment tablets periodically to prevent algae and scaling. Water Replacement: Depending on usage, you might need to change the water periodically. Consult your manual for specific guidance.
  4. Vacuum Floorspace: If possible, vacuum the area around and underneath the machine to prevent dust buildup which can affect the rollers and tracks.
  5. Inspect and Lubricate: Check moving parts such as the chain or cord, seat rollers, and any other mechanical components. If your model requires oiling or lubrication, use what the manufacturer recommends.
  6. Final Checks: Ensure all nuts, bolts, and screws are tightened. Check for signs of wear and tear and replace any parts as needed.
  7. Regular Maintenance: Make cleaning a part of your regular maintenance routine. Depending on usage, this could be monthly or more frequent.


Always refer to the manufacturer's manual for specific cleaning recommendations and any warnings related to your particular model to ensure you do not void your warranty or damage the equipment.


What is a magnetic rowing machine?

A magnetic rowing machine is a type of indoor rowing machine that uses magnetic resistance to create a smooth and quiet rowing experience. The resistance in these machines is generated by the interaction of magnets with a metal flywheel. Here's how it generally works and some key features:

  1. Magnetic Resistance: Unlike air rowers that use wind resistance or water rowers that use water, magnetic rowers use magnets positioned around the flywheel. Adjusting the magnetic field in relation to the flywheel changes the resistance level.
  2. Adjustability: These machines typically offer a wide range of resistance levels that can be easily adjusted, often through a digital console or manual dial, allowing users to customize their workout intensity.
  3. Smooth and Quiet Operation: One of the main advantages of magnetic rowing machines is that they operate quietly compared to other types of rowers, making them suitable for home use without disturbing others.
  4. Maintenance-Free: As there are no friction parts as seen in hydraulic or water rowers, magnetic rowing machines generally require less maintenance.
  5. Console and Features: Many magnetic rowers come equipped with consoles that display workout metrics such as time, distance, stroke rate, and calories burned. Some advanced models offer pre-set programs and connectivity with apps or heart rate monitors.
  6. Portability and Storage: Many models are designed to be foldable or come with wheels, making them easier to move and store when not in use.


Magnetic rowing machines are popular among users who want a low-impact full-body workout that can be performed quietly and efficiently at home. They are suitable for users of all fitness levels, from beginners to advanced athletes.


What is the average cost of a rowing machine?

The average cost of a rowing machine can vary widely based on several factors such as brand, features, and type (e.g., air resistance, water resistance, magnetic, or hydraulic). Generally, you can expect to spend:

  • Budget rowing machines: $100 to $300. These are more basic models, often hydraulic or magnetic resistance, suitable for beginners or those on a tight budget.
  • Mid-range rowing machines: $300 to $700. These machines offer better build quality, more resistance levels, and often have additional features like digital displays and performance tracking.
  • High-end rowing machines: $700 to over $1,500. These are typically the choice of serious rowers and gyms, offering the best quality, durability, and features. This category includes brands like Concept2 and WaterRower, known for their strong build and advanced performance tracking features.


Prices can vary by retailer and geographic location, and sales or promotional offers might affect the cost as well.


What is the significance of the drag factor in rowing?

In rowing, the drag factor is a crucial metric used to measure the resistance experienced by the rower when using an indoor rowing machine, specifically those equipped with a flywheel, like the Concept2 rowers. It represents how much air resistance is being applied to the flywheel and thus affects the effort needed to pull.


The significance of the drag factor includes:

  1. Calibration and Consistency: The drag factor allows rowers to ensure consistency across different rowing machines. Environmental factors such as dust buildup or varying air resistance can affect performance data, so standardizing the drag factor helps to ensure accurate and comparable results across sessions and different machines.
  2. Performance Optimization: Adjusting the drag factor lets rowers tailor the resistance to simulate different rowing conditions and optimize their performance. This can be akin to rowing on water in different boat sizes or varying environmental conditions (for example, a higher drag factor may simulate a larger boat or adverse weather conditions).
  3. Training Adaptation: By changing the drag factor, athletes can focus on different aspects of their training. A higher drag factor can help build strength, while a lower drag factor might be used for high-repetition, cardiovascular-focused training.
  4. Personal Preference and Technique: Different athletes have different rowing techniques and preferences. The drag factor can be adjusted to suit an individual’s style, allowing them to find the most efficient and comfortable setting for their stroke.
  5. Injury Prevention: Proper adjustment of drag factor can also help prevent injuries by ensuring that the rowing machine provides resistance that matches the rower's capabilities and physical condition.


Overall, understanding and adjusting the drag factor is essential for maximizing training effectiveness and achieving consistency in performance measurement on rowing machines.


How to improve rowing machine technique?

Improving your rowing machine technique involves focusing on form, consistency, and practice. Here are some tips to help enhance your technique:

  1. Master the Basic Phases: Catch: Begin with your knees bent, shins vertical, and arms extended forward. Keep your back straight and shoulders relaxed. Drive: Push through your feet and straighten your legs. Maintain a strong core and use your back and arms to create power. Finish: Keep the handle at your lower ribs, lean back slightly, and keep the wrists straight. Recovery: Let your arms extend first, then hinge at the hips and finally bend your knees, returning to the catch position.
  2. Focus on Posture: Maintain a strong, straight posture throughout the stroke. Avoid slouching or hunching over.
  3. Engage the Core: Use your core muscles to stabilize your body during the drive and finish, preventing undue strain on your back.
  4. Use Leg Power: Initiate the drive with a powerful push from your legs. They should do most of the work, with the back and arms contributing toward the end of the drive.
  5. Smooth Transitions: Ensure seamless transitions between each phase of the stroke. A controlled recovery is just as important as a powerful drive.
  6. Keep a Balanced Stroke Ratio: Aim for a 1:2 ratio between your drive and recovery phases. The drive is powerful but quick, while the recovery is more extended and controlled.
  7. Coordinate Breathing: Inhale during recovery and exhale during the drive. Proper breathing can help maintain rhythm and endurance.
  8. Monitor the Resistance: Adjust the damper setting to find a suitable resistance level that allows for proper stroke execution without excessive strain.
  9. Increase Stroke Rate Gradually: Start with a lower stroke rate (18-24 strokes per minute) to focus on form, then gradually increase the rate as technique improves.
  10. Record and Analyze Form: Use video recordings to review your form. This can help identify areas that need improvement.
  11. Seek Professional Guidance: Consider getting coaching from a certified rowing instructor to get personalized feedback and corrections.
  12. Practice Consistently: Regular practice is key to improvement. Consistency helps in building muscle memory and endurance.


Remember, refinement of technique takes time and patience. Emphasizing form over speed will lead to better efficiency and lower injury risk in the long run.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram Whatsapp Pocket

Related Posts:

Adjusting the resistance on a rowing machine is crucial for tailoring your workout to meet your fitness goals. Most rowing machines offer several methods to change resistance, depending on the type of machine you are using. If you have an air resistance rowing...
When comparing rowing machines to treadmills, the better option depends on individual fitness goals, preferences, and physical conditions. Rowing machines offer a full-body workout, engaging both the upper and lower body while providing cardiovascular benefits...
The best rowing machine for home use depends on several factors, including your budget, available space, fitness goals, and personal preferences. Some key considerations when choosing a rowing machine include resistance type, durability, ease of use, and addit...